Noise: Changed Direction of Real Estate Marketing
How real estate marketing went from selling FOMO to selling FEAR
Estimated read time: 6 minutes
In 2022, the real estate noise was almost entirely positive. Sold over asking. Buy now before you are priced out forever. Assignment sales. Investment properties. Real estate only goes up. Agents, mortgage brokers, investment groups, and social media personalities were all competing to say essentially the same thing, only louder. The market was hot, but the way it was being presented often went far beyond what was reasonable. It became a marketing machine built on excitement, urgency, and the fear of missing out.
That machine did not disappear when the market changed. It simply changed direction.
Now the headlines are about collapse, devastation, and comparisons to some of the worst markets in history. Every price reduction becomes evidence that the entire system is failing. Every struggling seller becomes another dramatic video. Every difficult set of statistics gets turned into a warning that things are about to become much worse. The optimism loop has become a negativity loop, but the goal often appears to be exactly the same. Get attention. Stay relevant. Keep people watching. Then remind them who to call when they need a Realtor, mortgage broker, or investment advisor.
How does someone benefit from constantly telling people that the market is getting worse? Usually, it is not because they are being paid directly for every frightening headline. The value is in the attention. Fear makes people stop scrolling. It creates comments, shares, arguments, and repeat viewers who begin to believe that the person delivering the warning understands something everyone else is missing.
That attention keeps an agent, mortgage broker, investment group, or online personality visible. Visibility can become leads, referrals, listings, mortgage business, consultations, coaching, or an audience that can be marketed to later. In that sense, fear is not always the product. Attention is the product, and fear is the tool being used to create it.
There is also a positioning benefit. The person becomes the brave truth teller, the one supposedly willing to say what the rest of the industry will not. That can be a legitimate and useful role when the analysis is thoughtful and balanced. It becomes something else when every new statistic is forced into the same catastrophic storyline because the audience has learned to expect another crisis.
“
The market noise changed direction. The incentives behind much of it did not.
Some of what is being said is true. This is a difficult market. Prices have fallen in many areas. Affordability remains terrible. Sellers are struggling to adjust, buyers are hesitant, and some people who purchased near the peak are in genuinely difficult situations. These things should be discussed openly. Market analysis matters, and there is nothing wrong with an occasional article, video, or post that explains what is happening and what it may mean.
The concern begins when negativity becomes the lead marketing strategy.
There is a difference between explaining a difficult market and building an entire public identity around keeping people anxious. There is a difference between helping someone understand risk and constantly searching for the next frightening statistic, failed listing, distressed seller, or dramatic comparison that might earn another click. When nearly every video or post needs the market to be crashing harder than it was yesterday, the public should start asking whether the person is analyzing the market or performing it.
This is the buyer beware part.
People should pay closer attention to the easy headlines and ask what is driving them. Is this person trying to help me understand what is happening, or are they trying to keep me emotionally activated? Is the information balanced and useful, or does everything somehow lead back to the same extreme conclusion? Does the person ever talk about markets, neighbourhoods, or property types that are behaving differently, or does every example exist only to support the brand they have built around negativity?
“
When negativity becomes the lead marketing strategy, the public should start asking what is really driving the message.
Sold Over Asking
One of the clearest examples of boom-market noise was the way “sold over asking” became a trophy, even when the asking price was part of the strategy. This article looks at how a technically true statement can still mislead the public when the context is left out.
Read the articleThe same scrutiny should apply to the people behaving as though nothing has changed.
A market shift this significant should have created some introspection within the real estate industry. Agents should be thinking about what they said in 2021 and 2022, the advice they gave, the tactics they celebrated, and the certainty they projected. They should also be examining how their own thinking has changed and what they have learned since then. I know I have.
That does not mean every Realtor has to publish a confession or apologize for working in a strong market. We were all working inside it, and anyone actively selling real estate benefited from it in some way. It does mean that someone who was loudly selling certainty then, and is loudly selling certainty now, should be willing to explain how they arrived at both positions. It also means that agents flying through this period with the same scripts, the same confidence, and the same lack of self examination should raise questions.
“
A changing market should have created some introspection within the real estate industry.
The market changed. Good advice should have changed with it.
The reality is far less dramatic than most internet content makes it appear. Real estate is not one market moving in one direction. It is small pockets, different property types, individual neighbourhoods, changing buyer groups, financing pressures, seller expectations, and personal circumstances. One seller may need to reduce their price. Another may be better off waiting. One buyer may have a genuine opportunity. Another may be taking on too much risk. Someone may need to downsize, upsize, renovate, rent, sell, stay put, or simply do nothing for another year.
That work is specific, patient, and often a little boring. It does not lend itself to dramatic thumbnails or endless predictions. There is no single headline that can tell every buyer or seller what to do, which is precisely why thoughtful real estate advice still matters.
A good Realtor should not need the market to be wonderful or catastrophic in order to be useful. Their value should come from understanding the details, asking the right questions, recognizing when circumstances are changing, and sometimes advising a client not to do anything at all. They should be able to discuss serious problems without turning fear into a business model. They should also be able to acknowledge past mistakes, reconsider old assumptions, and show that their thinking has evolved.
The market noise changed direction. The incentives behind much of it did not.
The public should be wary of anyone whose marketing depends on emotional extremes, whether the message is endless optimism or endless collapse. Fear can be just as self serving as hype. The fact that a message sounds negative does not automatically make it honest, objective, or brave.
Sometimes it is simply the latest way to stay in front of your face.